You can purchase this paper @ Office Max for $11.99 a ream. You get 250 sheets. Make sure you get the 110 lb weight. You can make 750 door hangers from 1 ream of paper! That is 750 homes that can be touch by your church!
This is the hole punch to punch the hole in the top of the door hanger. It is a Marvy Uchida hole punch. You can buy this at Michael's craft store or other craft stores. The hole punch cost around $6.
Any paper cutter will work. Make sure it is sharp so the cut is clean. You can cut 3 pages at a time.
You can use any pair of scissors. Once again make sure they are sharp so your cut is clean! You will be cutting an angle from the edge of the paper to the center hole. This allows the door hanger to slide over the knob or storm door handle.